Taggarts Ice Cream Parlor and Restaurant

My brother and sister-in-law took me to have dinner with his boss tonight and we ended up having ice cream at such a great place! Not only was the ice cream great, but the building is supposedly haunted! Right up my alley! There are two locations for Taggart’s: Canton, and Magnolia, OH.

The location in Magnolia is the one we visited. The town is adorable and the building that houses the restaurant is an old stage coach stop and inn built in 1830. The structure has been used in the past as a hotel, tavern, restaurant, pharmacy, pizza shop and t-shirt shop. Druscilla and Isaac Miller ran the inn years ago, and legend has it that their spirits have never left. Here are some accounts of strange happenings by people in the restaurant:

–A maintenance man heard footsteps in the building when no one else was there.

–Ice cream originally stored in the freezer, would be found somewhere else in the basement, melted. This has happened twice. The ice cream is stored in five-gallon containers.

–Chocolate sauce that is kept in the cooler has also been found out of place in some other part of the basement.

–A female employee of Taggarts had her hair pulled as she was coming out of the basement cooler. (I talked to her tonight and she told me the story!)

–On one occasion, there was coffee in the main dinning room coffee pot brewing when employees came
to work.

–A Taggarts employee observed a “shadow lady” sitting on a chair in the employees bathroom on the second floor.

–While sitting in the “tea room”, a group of teachers from a local school, were seated at a table having lunch, when a ketchup bottle and sugar packet flew off another table toward them. This occurred after one of the teachers commented on how ugly the wife of Isaac Miller was. A photo of Drusilla Miller hangs on the first floor near the main entrance. (I was told to make sure I didn’t say anything negative about her picture.)

Not a lot of great pictures, but what a cool place. You have to visit!

Share on FacebookTweet about this on TwitterPin on PinterestShare on Google+Share on LinkedInShare on TumblrEmail this to someone

Join the Discussion!

  1. Wow – some creepy stuff afoot in the Ice Cream joint! Well, Ginger was an ice cream affectionado, to be sure… but probably has nothing to do with the strange proceedings you have described.

    Glad to hear you are having fun, Kori…stay safe!


  2. OH MY GOSH!!! Ice Cream AND hauntings all in one place? I am soooooooooooooo there! LOL Wanna go back with me? The Bluebell Ice cream commercial here in Texas is, “We eat all we can and sell the rest”… we’ll just wait out some ghosts and eat all the ice cream… and then give the ghosts the rest!!!

    I’m off to read more and more!!!

    Have a great Thursday!!!
    ;-D robelyn

  3. thanks for putting my blog on yours…visit the blog when u r free and drop comments as per ur wish and even u dont like …drop comments.

    do follow my blog if u really like it means..

  4. I love me some ice cream, and some haunted stories. I just might have said something bad about the lady, just to see if something would happen. You know, to test out the haunted theory.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>